If you’ve ever asked yourself why your cookies turned out flat, too cakey, or just not chewy enough, this guide is for you. Whether you’re baking classic homemade cookies, soft and chewy chocolate chip cookies, or dreaming of bakery-style cookie perfection, this post will walk you through the differences, tips, and must-know techniques for mastering every kind of chocolate chip cookie.

A tall, messy pile of broken chocolate chip cookies sits on a white surface, with gooey chunks of chocolate peeking out from the soft, golden-brown pieces.

The 5 Types of Chocolate Chip Cookies

Not all chocolate chip cookies are created equal, from soft and chewy to thin and crispy. Each style comes with its texture, flavor, and method. Let’s break them down.

  • Classic
  • Chewy
  • Crispy
  • Bakery-Style
  • Mega
Four chocolate chip cookies—Bakery-Style, Chewy, Crispy, and Classic—are laid out on parchment paper, each showing off its unique look and texture. And to top it all off, there’s a giant one called Mega joining the crew.

Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies

These are the nostalgic, golden cookies you grew up loving—chewy middles loaded with chocolate chips. They’re made with a mix of butter and shortening for a balanced structure and brown sugar for a subtle caramel depth.

Common Issues: If your cookies spread too much or come out dry, the dough may be too warm or under-measured. Chilling, for 30 minutes or 3 hours, helps prevent overspreading and enhances flavor. Chilling is optional on this recipe.

Serving Suggestions: Stack warm cookies on a rustic wooden tray or serve with a cold glass of milk.

Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies

Want chewy chocolate chip cookies with tender centers? Browned butter and cornstarch are your best friends. More brown sugar = more chew.

Baking Tip: Chilling the dough is essential to help the fat solidify and deepen the flavors.

Troubleshooting: If they’re cakey, you may have added too much flour or over-mixed the dough.

Serving Suggestions: Pair with vanilla ice cream or drizzle with melted chocolate for bakery-worthy indulgence.

Three chocolate chip cookie dough balls—Bakery Style, Classic, and Chewy—are lined up on a white plate with a cool black rim, each packed with chocolate chips, all set out on a wooden table.

Crispy Chocolate Chip Cookies

Thin, snappy edges and a satisfying crunch throughout are ideal for coffee dunking or cookie tins. To get that crispy texture, increase the white sugar ratio and bake slightly longer at a lower temperature.

Troubleshooting: If your cookies are turning soft overnight, let them cool fully before storing in an airtight tin lined with parchment. Over-baking or dark pans can also cause burnt bottoms.

Serving Suggestions: Serve with espresso or wrap in parchment for gifting.

Bakery-Style Chocolate Chip Cookies

These gourmet beauties are thin, have rippled, crispy edges, chewy centers, and a rich flavor thanks to a mix of cake and bread flour.

Troubleshooting: To avoid completely flat cookies, cream your butter and sugar for at least 2 minutes and chill the dough. Try using dark brown sugar or bittersweet chocolate if your cookies lack flavor.

Serving Suggestions: Display on a cake stand, sprinkle with sea salt, or serve café-style with cappuccinos.

Four kinds of chocolate chip cookies—Bakery-Style, Chewy, Crispy, Mega, and Classic—are sliced in half and laid out on white parchment paper so you can really see their different textures and thicknesses.

Mega-Style (Jumbo) Chocolate Chip Cookies

Oversized, gooey-centered, and thick enough to impress a bakery critic- mega cookies need careful portioning and the right flour mix to stay sky-high.

Troubleshooting: If the center is raw, reduce the dough height slightly and bake for a minute or two longer. If they spread too thin, the butter may be too soft.

Serving Suggestions: Use an ice cream sundae base, or wrap in parchment with twine for a bakery-style finish.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Troubleshooting

A lot of cookie baking, is choosing the right recipe. If you are intending to make a thick cookie but then make the bakery-style chocolate chip cookie, that recipe is meant to yield a thin cookie with crispy edges and a magically chewy center. When you pull the thin cookies out of the oven, you are bound to be disappointed. The recipe isn’t wrong and you didn’t make a mistake, your expectations weren’t managed. When choosing a recipe, be sure to read the description carefully so that you bake what you are intending.

My cookies are too flat and greasy– Use cold butter (like in the Mega Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe) or chill the dough.

They turned out dry and crumbly– Increase the brown sugar or slightly underbake. I always pull cookies out of the oven slightly underbaked because they will finish baking on the hot pan while they set.

The texture isn’t what I expected– Choose your recipe wisely; when you understand the science of the cookie, you can start to predict what type of cookie it will make, even if the recipe description isn’t clear. For example, when a recipe includes cake flour, it will make a soft cookie; if there is bread flour, the cookie will have a chewy structure.

My crispy cookies turned soft overnight– Store cooled cookies in parchment-lined tins or other airtight containers.

A stack of chocolate chip cookies, each sliced in half and labeled with different textures—Classic, Chewy, Crispy, Bakery-Style, and Mega—lined up from top to bottom on parchment paper.

Common Chocolate Chip Cookie Questions

What’s the secret to chewy chocolate chip cookies? Brown sugar, browned butter, and chilling the dough.

How do you make crispy chocolate chip cookies stay crunchy? Use more white sugar, bake longer, and store in parchment-lined tins or airtight containers.

What’s the difference between classic and bakery-style cookies? Classic cookies use all-purpose flour and have a modest spread. Bakery-style cookies use cake and bread flour and have a chewy, elevated texture with a crisp outer edge.

How do you keep mega cookies from being raw in the middle? Slightly flatten the dough and avoid overcrowding the pan.

What’s the best flour for crispy vs. chewy cookies? Crispy uses all-purpose flour; chewy generally uses a mix of cake and bread flour.

Serving Suggestions

Chocolate chip cookies are a versatile dessert. Serve warm with milk, or cooled and stacked high. Add some vanilla ice cream or melted chocolate drizzle. Pair with coffee, present on a cake stand sprinkled with flaky sea salt. Use as a sundae base, milkshake companion, or wrapped in parchment paper for gifting.

Recommended Products

Black KitchenAid stand mixer with stainless steel bowl; sleek design, multi-speed control knob.
Two silver aluminum baking sheets, slightly offset, on a white background. Smooth surfaces with raised edges. Ideal for baking and roasting.
Stainless steel ice cream scoop with spring-loaded handle, black rubber grips, and lever for easy-release serving.
Package features orange and white design with food images, labeled Extra Strong. Open booklet of white parchment sheets in front.
Three red measuring spoons with white handles shown. Ideal for cookie baking. Two spoons detached in front; one attached to handle with embossed branding. White background.
Previous
Next

The 5 Types of Chocolate Chip Cookies

Chocolate chip cookies are more than just a sweet treat- they’re edible comfort, shareable joy, and a canvas for creativity. Whether baking a chewy batch with brown butter or stacking crispy cookies for a brunch spread, you’re part of a long and delicious tradition. Make sure to try all 5!